Showing posts with label Ruth Starke. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ruth Starke. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 February 2015

My Gallipoli

My Gallipoli by Ruth Starke and Robert Hannaford (Working Title Press)
HB RRP $29.99
ISBN9781921504761
Reviewed by Dianne Bates

This is a timely picture book for older readers with the centenary of the Anzac landing at Gallipoli Peninsula this April. The first page after the title page shows a map to indicate where Anzac Cove is located, with a magnified section that takes in places such as No Man’s Land, Lone Pine and Wire Gully. The narrative comes from the viewpoints of men (and women) involved in the battle.

To start the story, shepherd, Adil Sakin, whose village is north-east of Anzac Cove, speaks from Anzac Cove in November 1914 where he says army men came to his village speaking about the Great War. Adil announces his intention of fighting for the peninsular which has belonged to his family for hundreds of years. Then the story moves to 25 April 1915 where Midshipman Peter Burch RN is waiting in a boat to be landed on Anzac Cove. Burch tells how shooting started even before soldiers reached shore and how many died.

As the story progresses, other characters embroiled in the battle speak of their personal involvement. There’s a private from the Turkish army, a nursing sister on a hospital ship, a Ghurkha from Nepal (fighting in the British Army), an Australia chaplain, a New Zealand Private, and so on. One of the best-known narrators is Australia’s official war correspondent, C.E.W. Bean. Everyone who speaks, tells of the war from his or her perspective. The narrators speak from places such as Suvla Bay, Cape Helles and No Man’s Land. Each entry is prefaced by the place and the date. Towards the end of the battle we see a crippled soldier in Melbourne, a lieutenant charged with identifying and reburying remains of Allied soldiers, several cemetery scenes and Australia’s war artist, George Lambert, at work in Anzac Cove. There is no sense of victory, as there never ought to be with any war.

Without doubt a great deal of commendable research has gone into covering all of the various aspects of the battle which is unveiled with each narrator. There are also three end pages of notes with commentaries and illustrations of those real-life characters that appear in the story, and of geographical landmarks, etc. In addition, there is a bibliography, which includes another Working Title Press title by author Ruth Starke (An Anzac Tale, 2013).

The illustrations use charcoal sketches and watercolour depicting those aspects which are highlighted in the narrative, such as a nurse tending a soldier by lamp-light, men digging graves, soldiers exhausted in the trenches, men on furlong. It’s a real-life, comprehensive view of those hard, bloody days.


What I most like about this book is its interesting and well-written multi-narrative viewpoints; this is not just about Australia’s role in the battle, but an overall view. What I didn’t particularly like in this otherwise handsome production was the smallish typeface. For sure there is a lot of text employed, but for some readers aged 9 to 12 years, the font size might be too small. 

Tuesday, 19 March 2013

An Anzac Tale


An Anzac Tale by Ruth Starke, illustrated by Greg Holfeld (Working Title Press)
HB RRP $29.95
ISBN 9781921504532
Reviewed by Vicki Thornton

Roy Martin and his best mate Wally Cardwell are among the first to enlist when Australia goes to war at the beginning of World War 1. Eager to fight for King and country, they soon discover the adventure they thought they would have is nothing but a disaster.  One day after the unsuccessful landing at Anzac Cove on 25 April 1915, more than 2000 of their fellow ANZACs are dead.

The two mates and their new friend Tom, soon have to endure a battle against a tireless enemy, hostile surroundings, and the onset of flies, fleas, cold and disease.

This graphic novel is extraordinary for many reasons. Ruth Starke has captured the ‘aussie’ spirit of get up go really well. Australian slang of the time, words such as ‘little tacker’s ‘six bob tourists’ all add to the sense of the era.

The illustrations by Greg Holfeld help to create a unique book. The use of animals personalising the story, native animals for Australia, and the caracal lynx for the Turkish soldiers, helps the reader take a step back. This allows the horror of  war and what actually happened to penetrate.

The careful choice of language and what is told is taken hand in hand with the select illustrations. A combination of pen and ink and colour washes, used most effectively.  Most memorable is the double page spread of a confrontation between the ANZACs and the Turks…not a word is necessary and the thorough use of the illustrations says more than words ever could.

This book would be a great introduction of young readers to the topic of Gallipoli and the ANZAC campaign. With maps, timelines and pages of information, with the easy-to-read aspect of a graphic novel, it would also appeal to boys and reluctant readers.

A truly amazing and powerful picture book.

Wednesday, 29 June 2011

Captain Congo and the Klondike Gold

Captain Congo and the Klondike Gold by Ruth Starke & Greg Holfeld (Working Title Press)
HB RRP $24.95
ISBN 978 1 92150427 3
Reviewed by Jenny Mounfield

Fans of the previous two Congo titles: Captain Congo and the Crocodile King (which made history as the first graphic novel to be shortlisted by the Children’s Book Council of Australia) and Captain Congo and the Maharaja’s Monkey will be more than happy with Congo and Pug’s latest baddie-busting adventure. This time the impeccably mannered Congo and his faithful penguin buddy Pug are off to the north-west Canadian wilds to investigate ghostly goings-on in a gold camp. Could the strange lights and monster sightings be otherworldly, or is there a more earthly explanation? Naturally our intrepid pair will get to the bottom of the mystery—that is if they survive the train ride and the pulverising rapids.

This book—indeed this series—is an interesting mix of Scooby-do meets James Bond, with a dash of Get Smart thrown in for added flavour. The humour is by far the stand out here and it translates perfectly through Holfeld’s illustrations. On which score I simply must mention the last page which contains a full-page illustration with a laugh out loud punch line that is sheer genius. (But don’t be tempted to skip ahead; the joke will mean nothing without having read the story.)

There is, however, one gripe I have concerning this, and the previous two titles and it’s a design issue: the italicised text. Italics are generally harder on the eye than other fonts, even without the poor vision I am afflicted with, and since these books are aimed at reluctant readers, I can’t help but feel a more eye-friendly font would have been preferable.

With a chuckle on every page, Congo and Pug’s latest mission will prove a hit with kids and adults alike. Old-fashioned skulduggery, adventure and wit—there really is nothing like it.

Ruth Starke has authored over 20 titles and has far too many accolades to name. With his roots in animation and cartooning, Grey Holfeld has illustrated a number of picture books. His first, The Perfect, Pet was nominated for a Crchton Award.

Jenny Mounfield is the author of three novels for kids, her most recent title being: The Ice-cream Man (Ford St). She has been reviewing for Buzz Words since ’06 and also contributes to The Compulsive Reader: www.compulsivereader.com